My issue is with the cost, the lack of academic rigor, and decreasing amounts of intellectual honest/integrity.
I also, for the record, like the idea of having people from diverse backgrounds co-exist...or try to.
However, one of the most commonly cited criticisms by students (and adults) of a traditional liberal arts education is:
"When will I ever use that [history, English, philosophy, art, literature, psychology, etc.] in REAL life?"
Well, let me tell you a story.
In college, I took two semesters of a class from one of the world's foremost experts on French history, Orest Ranum.
The first was called "French Government in Thought and Practice from 1648-1715." The second was either the period immediately before or after that. Sorry, can't remember.
Anyway, that's about as good as an example as you will find of a class that would seemingly have no future practical value.
So, let me tell you a story.
A few months ago, I was at a dinner with a number of very (and I do mean very) successful business people.
I don't know the total net worth of the table, but easily into the billions.
I happened to be sitting next to the investment banker for one of them.
Turns out...he's French.
We start talking and he was naturally skeptical that I, being American, know all that much about France.
After all, he would normally be right. The average American sadly doesn't have a serious depth of knowledge about France.
Well, thank you Orest Ranum.
After I shared my thoughts on the Edict of Nantes among other things, we discussed some of the various regions in France.
The result? I could tell he was relaxed.
That led to us having a pretty in-depth conversation and establishing mutual trust.
I remember thinking afterwards....
"you want to know when you will use a French history class that you took in college?
You'll use it nearly 30 later at a dinner with one of the world's top investment bankers who happens to French. You won't use it to show off, but to show him (or her) that you are educated, thoughtful, and appreciate other people's histories outside of America. This will set you apart as different, which is what you are trying to do."